When I was describing weekend plans to go see the musical Strictly Ballroom in Toronto, a friend asked if it was like a smart Dirty Dancing.
Must say that I’ve never thought of Strictly Ballroom as such. Or spent much time comparing those two movies.
But it is true that they have the same basic plot line: Hunky male dance instructor teaches promising if slightly gawky young woman (from a different background) to dance, and they fall in love.
So how do they differ? I’m not so sure it’s on IQ points.
1. Point of view
Dirty Dancing is Baby’s story. It’s about her coming of age. It’s directed by a woman, and we see most everything from her perspective. Johnny is there to support her narrative.
Whereas Strictly Ballroom is about Scott. It’s about him breaking free of family expectations and becoming his own person. Fran helps on that journey. Yes, she does that blossoming thing, but that’s really just to make her attractive enough to become Scott’s love interest.
Dirty Dancing is a bit of nostalgia for a time that was and no longer is, when teenagers would happily go off with their parents to a summer vacation resort. Whereas Strictly Ballroom both salutes and mocks the world of ballroom dance competition, in which everyone is trying to preserve a form of dance that—let’s face it—is no longer current.
And as I write that, I’m thinking maybe that’s another similarity: That both movies are about the struggle to preserve a tradition against the forces of change. Hmm.
Despite the romance at the centre of it and plenty of humourous moments, Dirty Dancing is basically a drama, the story told in a “realistic” way. Whereas Strictly Ballroom is very much an over-the-top, exaggerated comedy, albeit with some touching moments.
Which is why Dirty Dancing opens itself up to criticism when some of the dialog is clunky or if a character seems more like a caricature. Strictly Ballroom is in-your-face with ridiculous dialog and absurd characters; that’s part of its charm.
And that also may be why, in my opinion, another difference between these two is that Strictly Ballroom made its transition to the stage much more effectively than Dirty Dancing did.
It’s been a while since I saw Dirty Dancing: The Musical, but I recall thinking that they shouldn’t have stuck so close to the movie. That this might have an opportunity to, for example, fix some of the sillier plot points.
Strictly Ballroom also stuck pretty close to the movie template. But in this case, just the nature of the stage presentation improved the product.
A lot of it is ballroom dance competition, for example. In the movie, these scenes are largely funny and absurd. On stage, they still have that to a degree, but they also enchanting and beautiful. It just feels more “natural” to see that kind of dancing and those wild costumes on a theatre stage than a movie screen.
And then there’s what musicals do, which is allow the characters to give voice to their inner thoughts in song. And that really brought a lot of depth to the story, making many of the characters less cartoonish. They even bring in some of that Dirty Dancing nostalgia by including popular songs of the 1980s as part of the soundtrack. It really widens the range of emotion of the whole enterprise.
I love the movie Strictly Ballroom. But I think I loved the musical even more.
July 2, 2017 at 1:25 pm
Thank you for inadvertently pointing out why I love Dirty Dancing despite it’s flaws. I’d never considered the female protagonist, male as secondary character, female director before, but that’s it. That is likely the reason right there because it happens so rarely in American film (and even more rarely in the 1980s. Did you ever review the Dirty Dancing musical to discuss those plot points they didn’t fix? I’d like to hear your thoughts on it.
July 2, 2017 at 2:48 pm
Yes, I think that’s why I do, too. I was actually getting kind of annoyed, writing this, to realize that “Strictly Ballroom” is another guy’s story, with Fran basically a manic pixie girl trope.
But I don’t think I did review the “Dirty Dancing” musical at the time. Probably unmotivated due to disappointment with it. Would have been a handy reference if I had…
July 3, 2017 at 7:28 am
I remember enjoying “Strictly Ballroom” as a brilliant comedy that affectionately satirized the world of ballroom dance. I didn’t realize there’s a musical–sounds great!
July 3, 2017 at 11:07 am
I just learned from Wikipedia that it actually started as a play, that was then adapted as a movie. The musical version started in Australia, then played London, then Toronto. (I also hadn’t realized that Toronto was the North American premiere for it.)
July 3, 2017 at 1:14 pm
That’s really interesting. I knew it had an Australian connection but I hadn’t realized that it began onstage.